Online Auction Fraud

Oct 12, 2025 | Articles

Don’t Let it Happen to You

Computers, sports memorabilia, rare coins, designer fashions, and even cars.

These are just a few of the items offered for sale every day on legitimate online auction sites. They’re also just a small sample of the items used to lure unsuspecting victims into online auction fraud schemes.

Most of the one million-plus transactions that take place each day on these websites are legitimate; just a fraction actually result in some type of fraud.

But even that fraction adds up. According to the latest report of the Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3), more than 70,000 complaints made to IC3 last year—about one in every four—involved online auction scams.

There are a variety of auction frauds, but here are some of the more common ones to watch out for:

  • Overpayment fraud targets the seller. A seller advertises a high-value item—like a car or a computer—on the Internet. A scammer contacts the seller to purchase the item, then sends the seller a counterfeit check or money order for an amount greater than the price of the item. The purchaser asks the seller to deposit the payment, deduct the actual sale price, and then return the difference to the purchaser.
  • Wire transfer schemes start with fraudulent and misleading ads for the sale of high-value items being posted on well-known online auction sites. When buyers take the bait, they are directed to wire money to the crooks using a money transfer company. Once the money changes hands, the buyer never hears from them again.
  • Second-chance schemes involve scammers who offer losing bidders of legitimate auctions the opportunity to buy the item(s) they wanted at reduced prices. They usually require that victims send payment through money transfer companies, but then don’t follow through on delivery.

And needless to say, in all of these schemes customers never get what they pay for.

Who is behind the scams. Mostly individuals. However, there are exceptions: criminal enterprises from West Africa are especially fond of the overpayment scams, while Romanian crime groups favor the second-chance schemes.

We’re working to address the problem. We’ve had a number of successful auction fraud investigations, worked collaboratively with other agencies, including one in Virginia and one in Texas.

What to do if you’ve been victimized. Go to the Internet Crime Complaint Center or the Federal Trade Commission websites and submit a complaint. The more we know about the extent of the crime—including the specific methods being used to perpetrate it—the more effective we can be in preventing and investigating these scams. You can also report incidents to your local police and to auction companies.

So, how can you avoid being a victim of auction fraud? A few tips:

  • Ask the seller for a phone number and verify it.
  • Beware of buyers who insist on wire transfers as the only form of payment they’ll accept.
  • For big-ticket items, use a legitimate online escrow service that will hold the payment until you receive what you’ve ordered.
  • If you receive an overpayment as a seller, don’t cash it but instead ask for the exact purchase price.
  • Don’t ever give out your social security or driver’s license number—a legitimate seller wouldn’t ask.
  • Be skeptical if the price sounds too low.

Source:
FBI Online Auction Fraud
https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/news/stories/2009/june/auctionfraud_063009

Other Articles You May Be Interested In

2025 Hall of Fame Inductee

2025 Hall of Fame Inductee

Congratulations to our 2025 Hall of Fame Inductee, Carol Wagenson! Carol holds the Certified Auction Institute (CAI) designation from the National Auctioneers Association. Carol is also a Wisconsin State Champion Auctioneer (2012) and has competed in the...

New updated contestant rules

New updated contestant rules

The rules for the champions contest have been updated for 2023. Wisconsin Auctioneers Association (WAA) WI Championship Auctioneer Contest Rules (Revised 2022) The full name of the contest is “WISCONSIN AUCTIONEERS ASSOCIATION, INC. AUCTIONEER CHAMPIONSHIP.” There...

Scouting America’s Test Lab

Scouting America’s Test Lab

The National Auction Association is thrilled to announce the launch of an exciting new offering in Scouting America's* Test Lab! This innovative lab allows Scouts to explore unique opportunities on a limited-time basis, with the most popular options earning a...

Frederic Wiese Obituary

Frederic Wiese Obituary

Wiese, Frederic Lee age 57, Passed away in the arms of his loving wife and soulmate Kristine on August 2nd after a brief illness and after beating cancer twice. Frederic was born in Maquoketa Iowa and graduated from Fenimore high school in 1986. He was active...

2025 New Board Members

2025 New Board Members

We welcome two new WAA Board Members Jacqui Engler with Superior Auction LLC Born in Sturgeon Bay and raised in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, I am a proud Midwesterner with a strong commitment to family and a passion for entrepreneurship. From a young age, I...

Sherman Hostetter, Jr. – Bio

Sherman Hostetter, Jr. – Bio

Sherman Hostetter, Jr. of Beaver, Pennsylvania, attended Penn State University on a Golf Scholarship from 1973-77 and graduated with a major in real estate and insurance. Presently, he continues the family auction business, started by his parents in 1955, as a full...

75th Anniversary Celebration

75th Anniversary Celebration

75 YEARS STRONG: The Ultimate Celebration for Wisconsin Auctioneers! Calling ALL Wisconsin Auctioneers: THIS is YOUR moment to ELEVATE your game, connect with the BEST in the business, and SUPERCHARGE your professional future! Celebrating 75 INCREDIBLE Years:...